 |
Assiniboine River Water Supply and Flood Control Project
|
 |
1.
|
Q
|
What is being proposed / what will the project entail?
|
 |
|
A
|
An $8 million Canada-Manitoba funding agreement has been signed to provide compensation to upstream land
owners in Saskatchewan, to acquire additional upstream land in Saskatchewan, to study downstream impacts
in Manitoba, and to upgrade the Shellmouth Dam.
Compensation is being paid upstream in Saskatchewan on lost income to farmers due to seeding delays
as a result of reservoir operation. A compensation package is being implemented with respect to past
damages, and land control is being obtained to preclude future claims.
Downstream impacts in Manitoba as a result of the operation of the Shellmouth Dam, particularly the
reach of river from the dam to Provincial Trunk Highway (PTH) 16, will be studied in detail under
this agreement, including costs for mitigation.
In regards to the dam itself, the proposal calls for the addition of gates to the crest of the
spillway to enhance downstream water supply and flood control.
|
 |
2.
|
Q
|
Why is this initiative necessary?
|
 |
|
A
|
Water supply enhancement is not needed today on the Assiniboine River, but it
is projected that, at some point in the future, demand for water may outstrip
supply. For example, the needs of existing vegetable processors, plans for future
potato processing plant expansion, establishment of potential ethanol production
facilities and requirements for municipal water supply expansion could consume the
estimated current unallocated annual water supply of 20,000 acre-feet. It is
important to plan for the future to ensure that Manitoba is poised to capture
economic growth in the agriculture sector, while at the same time providing
flows in the river to maintain water quality and support aquatic life, and providing flood protection.
|
 |
3.
|
Q
|
Who will benefit?
|
 |
|
A
|
The Shellmouth Dam was originally constructed to reduce flood risk and improve security
of water supplies for Manitobans who live and work on the Assiniboine River. The proposed
project would further benefit downstream municipalities, industry, farmers and irrigators
through enhanced flood control and water supply.
|
 |
4.
|
Q
|
What is the time line for this project?
|
 |
|
A
|
The project began in the summer of 2003. It is expected that the detailed
environmental and engineering studies, including public consultations, will be completed
by early 2005, followed by one year of construction. The project is expected to be completed
by March 31, 2006.
|
 |
5.
|
Q
|
How will the project be funded?
|
 |
|
A
|
The $8 million funding agreement calls for a 50/50 cost-sharing formula between
Canada and Manitoba. The actual funding breakdown is as follows:
| Upstream compensation |
$1.5 million |
| Upstream land control |
$2.4 million |
| Dam upgrading |
$4.0 million |
| Downstream studies |
$0.1 million |
| Total |
$8.0 million |
|
 |
6.
|
Q
|
Why are upstream farmers being compensated for past
damages, while downstream Manitoba farmers have not?
|
 |
|
A
|
The upstream issue in Saskatchewan on lost income to farmers due to seeding delays as a result of
reservoir operation was confirmed. A compensation package is being implemented with respect to past
damages and land control.
The downstream issues in Manitoba, including the reach of river from the dam to PTH 16, will be
studied in detail under this agreement, including definition and costs for mitigation. Canada and
Manitoba will consult with individuals and communities downstream of the dam, including First
Nations, farm groups, Metis, municipalities, and other interested parties throughout the course of the project.
|
 |
7.
|
Q
|
Is this proposal the best option?
|
 |
|
A
|
Over the past several decades many options for enhancement of Assiniboine
River water management have been studied, including the merits of adding
gates to the dam. It initially appears that adding gates to the crest of
Shellmouth Dam to improve operational flexibility may be the best option,
based upon cost and benefit analysis. However, a detailed review of past
studies and environmental issues associated with options for Assiniboine
River management will be undertaken to determine whether the installation
of gates is the best option for this project.
|
 |
8.
|
Q
|
Will the dam be operated differently to improve water
supply and flood control?
|
 |
|
A
|
The dam would have to be operated differently to achieve the anticipated benefits.
It is currently operated by drawing it down in winter to make room for storage of spring
flood flows. The level of draw-down is managed so that enough water remains to be released
over the following summer. In spring time the dam is allowed to fill while downstream flows
are held low to reduce flood flows. Adding gates to the main works of the dam will extend the
range of operation, and improve the storage capacity for flood control and water supply.
|
 |
9.
|
Q
|
Will there be an environmental assessment and review of the
proposed project?
|
 |
|
A
|
The project is likely to require both federal and provincial approvals. A project description
is being prepared which will be submitted to federal and provincial authorities for determination
of the environmental assessment process. It is anticipated that a detailed environmental impact
assessment will be required. As such, work has already begun in identifying potential
environmental effects.
|
 |
10.
|
Q
|
Is any public consultation planned?
|
 |
|
A
|
One of the project management team's first steps will be to engage in public
consultation - to explain the project development process and to gauge public
concern. Follow-up consultations will take place during the detailed environmental
assessment phase of the project. There will also be opportunity for public input during the regulatory
review stage of the assessment.
|
 |
11.
|
Q
|
Would residences and other existing works on Lake of the
Prairies be impacted by changed operation and higher water levels?
|
 |
|
A
|
It has not yet been determined what the impacts may be. However, the reservoir will
certainly have to be operated at higher levels to improve water supply and flood control
potential. As part of the study, a range of operating scenarios and potential impacts will
be studied, in consultation with local residents. It is possible that some existing works
on the reservoir would have to be altered as a result of changes to reservoir operation.
|
 |
12.
|
Q
|
Would the fishery on Lake of the Prairies or downstream on the
Assiniboine River be impacted?
|
 |
|
A
|
Changes to the operation of Lake of the Prairies and possible impacts to the fishery will be
studied in detail before any commitment to changing reservoir works or operation are made.
Although additional water supply / capacity may serve to enhance prospects with respect to
downstream aquatic life, it is unknown at this time whether improved storage potential would
be a benefit or a detriment to the fishery.
|